9 Party-Approved Popcorn Recipes That Aren’t Just Buckets of Butter (2024)

Movie nights are inevitable during winter. Whether you live somewhere cold and refuse to leave the house when it’s below 30°F (-1°C) (wise decision) or just live for Freeform’s 25 Days of Christmas movies, you and your couch are about to get some extra quality time. All the more reason for a movie snack upgrade.

When you make popcorn at home, you’re pretty much guaranteed to come up with something more nutritious than a movie theater bag… Those nutrition facts are downright frightening. But that doesn’t mean you need to skimp on flavor. These recipes show you how to make your popcorn sweet, savory, or spicy, with just a few extra ingredients.

1. Brown butter cinnamon sugar popcorn

9 Party-Approved Popcorn Recipes That Aren’t Just Buckets of Butter (1)Share on Pinterest

Brown sugar cinnamon will forever remind us of our favorite childhood toaster pastries, and it turns out the flavor combo tastes just as good on popcorn. After all, you really can’t go wrong with cinnamon, sugar, and butter (ever). Melt the butter in a saucepan and let it turn to a golden brown color, then pour it over your ‘corn and sprinkle with cinnamon and sugar.

Give this recipe a try here.

2. Oven-roasted pizza popcorn

You had us at pizza. This popcorn would also be great to serve at a party or game day, and it definitely makes enough to feed a crowd. For the most part, you just need to raid your spice cabinet: This popcorn uses paprika, sea salt, garlic powder, oregano, and basil, plus a dash of hot sauce and freshly grated Parm. Ain’t no party like a pizza popcorn party.

Let’s get our pizza flavors on here.

3. Cinnamon bun popcorn

Share on Pinterest

Protein popcorn might make your eyes roll, but trust us on this one. When you blend a scoop of vanilla protein powder with cinnamon and sweetener (like coconut sugar), you barely notice the taste. And by spraying the popcorn with coconut oil cooking spray, the cinnamon bun mix will stick well to the popcorn.

Grab the recipe here.

4. Spicy lime popcorn

Share on Pinterest

If you like your snacks to pack a little heat, this one’s for you. It’s heavy on the spices, with a mix of cumin, chili powder, cayenne, oregano, garlic powder, onion powder, and salt. Lime juice and zest give it just the right amount of tang. We’re not saying you should snack on this with a marg in hand, but it wouldn’t be the worst idea in the world, either.

Learn this spicy treat here.

5. Dark chocolate sea salt popcorn

Share on Pinterest

Chocolate and sea salt: A true classic. Popcorn is the perfect vehicle to get these two flavors in your mouth, and it’s crazy simple to make. Just melt a handful of dark chocolate chips, drizzle it over popcorn, and sprinkle with sea salt. The hard part? Trying to leave some for tomorrow.

Snag the recipe here.

6. Healthy popcorn trail mix

Share on Pinterest

Popcorn is less the main event here and more of a fun addition. You can pop your own on the stovetop, use a microwave bag, or grab some of your favorite pre-packaged kernels. Mix your popcorn of choice with cashews, sunflower seeds, dried apricots, and cranberries, and shake it up. Easiest trail mix ever with lots of nutrients.

Head over here for the recipe.

7. Everything bagel popcorn

Share on Pinterest

Shout out to Trader Joe’s (and now so many others!) for making Everything but the Bagel seasoning, which turns this recipe into an easy two-step process. If you don’t start with a buttered popcorn, we recommend drizzling a little on top or spraying the popcorn with coconut oil spray before sprinkling with the seasoning.

Grab this recipe here.

8. Trail mix popcorn balls

Share on Pinterest

A post-workout snack that includes popcorn? Count us in. Making them in cupcake liners is a pretty genius idea and makes grabbing one on the run so easy. The energy balls don’t actually require any baking, just refrigeration so all the nuts, popcorn, dates, and PB can meld together.

Energy up with the recipe here.

9. Holiday Santa munch mix

Share on Pinterest

You kind of have to make this festive snack sometime during the holiday season… it’s too cute not to. Santa munch is made with popcorn, pretzels, nuts, white chocolate chips, and holiday M&Ms. Apparently, Santa likes to nom on all the same snacks we do, so looks like we’re making double.

‘Tis the season to snag this recipe.

9 Party-Approved Popcorn Recipes That Aren’t Just Buckets of Butter (2024)

FAQs

What to use instead of butter for popcorn? ›

Here's a list of excellent butter substitutes for popcorn for your next batch.
  • Olive Oil. Olive oil is a healthy and tasty alternative to butter. ...
  • Trail Mix. Adding trail mix to your popcorn can introduce a variety of flavors while also providing a healthy alternative to butter. ...
  • Coconut Oil. ...
  • Avocado Oil. ...
  • Ghee. ...
  • Canola Oil.
Jan 3, 2023

What are good mix-ins for popcorn? ›

Whether you want a sweet and salty mix or a strictly sweet treat, these 9 awesome candies will work wonderfully in your recipe.
  • White Chocolate Chips. White chocolate chips are amazing with salty popcorn. ...
  • Candy Corn. ...
  • Sprinkles. ...
  • Milk Chocolate Fudge. ...
  • Oreos. ...
  • Peanut Butter Cups. ...
  • M&M's. ...
  • Mini Marshmallows.
Apr 17, 2023

How to make popcorn a more filling snack? ›

If you're looking for a way to create popcorn that is more filling than your typical bowl, we recommended adding peanut butter! A healthy popcorn topping, the peanut butter adds a boost of protein and flavor to your bowl that both children and adults will love.

What are good seasonings to put on popcorn? ›

Combine melted butter, paprika, lemon pepper, salt, garlic powder, onion powder, and cayenne pepper in a small bowl; pour over popcorn and stir until it is somewhat evenly coated.

How to make popcorn taste like the movies? ›

Instead, these two key ingredients give movie theater popcorn its signature taste and smell: popcorn popping oil and popcorn seasoning. Yup, it's that simple. Popcorn popping oils come in a few varieties, including pure coconut oil or a blend of canola oil.

Can you put regular melted butter on popcorn? ›

Can you just melt butter and put it on popcorn? Yes absolutely – it makes the best buttered popcorn if you do it this way. Be sure to shake it so the butter is evenly distributed throughout the kernels.

How to make popcorn in large quantities? ›

The Presto PopLite is the best of our picks at making a large quantity of popcorn quickly. In just about 2½ minutes, this machine transforms half a cup of kernels into roughly 18 cups of popcorn. By comparison, the Whirley-Pop has roughly the same capacity but takes about 4 minutes.

What can I do with bland popcorn? ›

Nearly Calorie Free Popcorn
  1. Shake on Frank's Red Hot or Tabasco sauce.
  2. Dusting of parmesan cheese.
  3. Red pepper flakes.
  4. Taco seasoning.
  5. Garlic and rosemary.
  6. Dill and lemon zest.
  7. Garlic-infused oil.
  8. Mist with coconut oil.
Mar 16, 2011

How to pimp up popcorn? ›

Roll up your popcorn with a crazy mix of nuts, chocolate chips, dried fruits and melted marshmallows, because hiking is always better when it's done indoors and without the mountain.

What is the secret ingredient in popcorn? ›

The flavor all comes down to one ingredient: Flavacol. You've likely never heard of Flavacol because, really, only movie theaters use it. Essentially, it's butter-flavored salt. It's a really fine, bright orange powder that adds that buttery flavor you crave and the signature yellow color.

How much popcorn do you need for a party? ›

The typical popcorn serving is 3 cups. For events, we use 2-2.5 cups per person as a starting point. Not everyone is going to want some and then the answers to the questions above will guide your estimate up or down.

Which flavor is best for popcorn? ›

Must-Try Savory Popcorn Flavors
  • Nacho Cheese Popcorn. ...
  • White Cheddar Popcorn. ...
  • Spicy Jalapeno Popcorn. ...
  • Dill Pickle Popcorn. ...
  • Imitation Movie Theater Popcorn. ...
  • Ranch Popcorn. ...
  • Cajun Popcorn. ...
  • Parmesan Cheese Popcorn.
Aug 24, 2023

Do you add seasoning before or after popping popcorn? ›

You add seasoning after popping the popcorn. However, keep in mind to always add your seasoning while the popcorn is still hot. That way, moisture residue from popping steam will help your seasoning stick to the popcorn.

How do you get powdered flavor to stick to popcorn? ›

Firstly toss the popcorn with some melted butter or oil first and then add the seasoning as soon as possible, this is the perfect way to stick seasoning to popcorn with little waste. Butter/oil is the usual method.

How can I flavor popcorn without oil or butter? ›

Use a liquid

Making your popcorn damp can help your seasonings stick to it more effectively. You can use: Soy sauce, tamari, Braggs aminos or coconut aminos. Vinegar.

Can popcorn be popped without oil or butter? ›

Pop your popcorn in a dry pan or skillet, no oil. Controversial, I know, but I find that popping popcorn in hot oil increases the likelihood of burnt popcorn and dead kernels. Dry pan popping results in beautiful light popcorn that provides the perfect blank canvas for all your favorite seasonings.

Can you replace oil with butter for popcorn? ›

A: Yes. I put 2 tablespoons of butter and 1/4 cup of popcorn in the bottom of the popper and pop until the popping slows down. It does nothing to harm the popper and as long as you don't overpop, the popcorn will not burn.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Prof. Nancy Dach

Last Updated:

Views: 5363

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (77 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Prof. Nancy Dach

Birthday: 1993-08-23

Address: 569 Waelchi Ports, South Blainebury, LA 11589

Phone: +9958996486049

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Web surfing, Scuba diving, Mountaineering, Writing, Sailing, Dance, Blacksmithing

Introduction: My name is Prof. Nancy Dach, I am a lively, joyous, courageous, lovely, tender, charming, open person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.